Reviews & Ratings for Prudhommes' Lost Cajun Kitchen

3 Star Rating: Average

6 reviews

What users are saying:

1 Star Rating: Poor

09/27/09

Bad Food

by jmyers325

I ordered the "Heart of the Bayou" seafood platter. I was brought a few small pieces of blackened catfish, 6 shrimp, and some clam strips all buried under a big pile of "straw onions" and two huge hush puppies". The small cup of jumbalaya was cold. This whole meal was exceedinly greasy and for $22, I was expecting a lot more seafood and not so much filler. The other people in my party were not too happy with their selections either - the crabby patty had some weird sauce that just didn't belong in the sandwich. Stay away from this place.

  • Pros: waitress was nice
  • Cons: worst meal I've had in a long time
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

08/24/09

Great

by CSMobileUser

Great food and great atmosohere. And the people were even better

1 Star Rating: Poor

07/26/09

Skip it

by tinaObeana

We were a group of 8 from a meetup, Many of us were quite excited after hearing good things about this place.

It took a bit till our apps came, sauteed gator had great flavor but is really chewy, The oysters with crab was tasty, cajun whoopie pie was good, it was a corn muffin with creamy crab, the corn muffin was really good and was the best part of my meal.

The shrimp Sunny is in a tomato sauce that was so bland, like watered down tomatoes, not even salt.

The Crabby Pork had creamy crab like the whoppie pie, had a dry pork loin and was served with mashed potaoes, weird.

The Rice and Beans had ham and sausage and was tasty, nice flavors

The jambalaya was cold, bland and dry

The Seafood Gumbo had no seafood that I could see or okra, olny onion and celery and was tastless except for a little hot spice.

I cant tell you about the crab louis, it took so long the woman who ordered had to leave and took it to go.

Between the Apps and Entree it took over an hour. They bought us a round of drinks while we waited. IF the food is really good you can overlook alot of other faults but this scored low all around.

You should skip it, really.

  • Pros: cajun whoppie pie, rice and beans
  • Cons: everything else was not so good
1 Star Rating: Poor

10/15/08

One star is 2 too many.. and no okra or crawdads?!?

by moatbuilder

I was really excited to see Cajun food up here with such shining reviews. Unfortunately I don't think anyone that works there or that has reviewed the place has ever actually eaten Cajun before. Being my first (and last) time there, I ordered something somewhat cajun (broiled oysters with lump crab meat), something EXTREMELY cajun ( bowl of gumbo) and my wife got a house creation (cajun pasta.) Everything was bland and runny. The only redeeming and slightly authentic part of the meal was my Abita Turbodog. Needless to say, I didn't stick around to try the whiskey bread pudding if it was even offered on the menu...

  • Pros: reasonable prices
  • Cons: if i lived above this place and ate for free, i'd still go somewhere else
4 Star Rating: Recommended

11/22/05

If you like cajun food, this is the place to go!

by columbiagirl

The restaurant area was non smoking, but the smell was very strong from the bar area, I left smelling like a cigarette! The bar area needs a better system to remove the smoke.

  • Cons: The cigarette smoke
5 Star Rating: Highly Recommended

09/04/04

Doesn't get any better!!

by smakin

Wow-can I get a room here? This is so neat, 108yr. old hotel and such a fun and wonderful place to eat, snack, drink, listen to live blues or check out monday night football with cool 1/2 time eats-and my dreams came true-they are opening 7 DAYS a week-about time!

  • Pros: happy, polite staff, options for any taste, clean b-rooms
  • Cons: , deck not open til '05, not open 24 hours!
Advertisement

Best of Citysearch

Time is running out!

Best of Citysearch Spa and Beauty

See More Lancaster Polls & Winners

Things To Do Nearby Prudhommes' Lost Cajun Kitchen

Prudhommes' Lost Cajun Kitchen

50 Lancaster Ave
Columbia, PA 17512

Advertisement